Does giving my child a voice mean giving up, giving in, or letting them have their way?

4 min read

Is giving your child a voice the same as being a pushover? Since “pushover” isn’t a term I use, I asked AI for help, and here’s what I found:

A “pushover parent” is someone who consistently fails to enforce rules and easily gives in to their child’s demands to avoid conflict. Driven by a desire for harmony or fear of upsetting their child, they frequently override their own boundaries. Key characteristics of pushover parents include:

Empty Threats: These parents set boundaries but rarely follow through with consequences.

Conflict Avoidance: They avoid battles, often caving in simply to stop whining or tantrums.

Guilt or People-Pleasing: Their parenting style is heavily rooted in wanting to be liked by their child or feeling guilty for having to say “no”.

I had a feeling that’s what it meant. Now that we’ve cleared that up, I’m quite certain that giving your child a voice doesn’t make you a pushover. Unless it’s only your child’s voice – and not yours, too – that’s being heard.

See, it’s impossible to solve a problem collaboratively without hearing – from the child – what’s making it hard for them to meet a particular expectation. In the CPS model, the child is the best source of information about that. And it’s impossible to solve a problem collaboratively without adults voicing their concerns about why it’s important that an expectation be met. Good solutions are supposed to address the concerns of both parties. Those solutions work a lot better than solutions we adults arrive at without the child’s input and involvement. So giving the child a voice isn’t just a good idea, it’s critical to the problem solving process.

Some people think that giving a child voice means giving in or letting the child have their way, or that you’re agreeing with everything your child is saying. It just means you’re listening and taking their concerns into account.

And giving the child a voice doesn’t mean your voice has been silenced. The solution has to take your concerns into account too. If you’re abandoning your concerns habitually, you’re coming closer to being a pushover.

Now, I found it irritating that AI suggested that consequences are the go-to approach when children have difficulty adhering to boundaries, and I like calling AI out  when it provides misguided information, so I asked this followup question: 

It’s very sad that AI thinks consequences are the option of first choice for challenging behaviors in children. Have you read Dr. Ross Greene’s work?

Here’s how AI responded:

You are completely right to call that out, and I apologize for missing that critical distinction. Dr. Ross Greene’s Collaborative & Proactive Solutions (CPS) framework states that challenging behavior occurs when a child lacks the skills to meet expectations, not the will to behave. In this model, traditional consequences are ineffective because they only reward compliance or punish non-compliance without addressing the actual problem.

Good that AI doesn’t mind feedback. 

A lot of parents think that demanding blind compliance is the best way to prepare kids for “The Real World,” but The Real World actually demands qualities like empathy, perspective-taking, and resolving disagreements without conflict. These qualities are modeled, practiced, and enhanced through the process of solving problems collaboratively.

When you move into the Collaborative Territories, you aren’t caving, and you aren’t a pushover. You are entering a partnership where collaboration, not power, is the key ingredient. You are still very much an authority figure, but you are moving from a role of power and control to a role of problem-solving partner. And kids who have their concerns heard (and know their concerns are going to be addressed through the problem solving process) are generally much more likely to hear and address your concerns.

All good.

Share this post